American “number one” and world #9 Mardy Fish has withdrawn from this weekend’s Davis Cup quarter-final tie in France, citing exhaustion or fatigue. For the tie, which will be played on outdoor red clay, Captain Jim Courier has called on world #66 Ryan Harrison to fill in for Fish. This marks the first time that the 19 year old Harrison will compete in live singles for the United States Davis Cup team. While French Captain Guy Forget said earlier that Harrison is a future prospect at this point, and not an established player, we feel he may be underestimating this weekend’s USA squad.
We can’t fault Courier here with his pick. You know we like Courier very much as DCC, and we haven’t really criticized him yet. We’ll make a minor criticism here. Courier opted to play Mardy Fish in the doubles with Mike Bryan, pulling Harrison when he felt America had best go for the definite doubles victory over Federer and Wawrinka, and they got the win. But in watching how Fish “hurt his partner”, according to our old friend Fred Stolle, when teamed with Bethanie Mattek Sands at The Hopman Cup, when his lazy play cost America the match, we grew very irritated with Fish as a doubles player as well. Fish had played earlier that day in Perth, and we guess he was exhausted. Though that is no excuse. We thought Courier should have gone for Isner in that spot. Isner was hot, and he’s the guy that’s won a few doubles titles lately, and not Fish.
Then Mardy Fish goes on and has a pretty pedestrian start to the year. Then he gets flipped by Juan Monaco in Miami, one and three. I’m sorry, but that’s a poor effort. Mardy Fish has got to do better there in that spot. On hards, in Florida, heavy favorite. Okay. We lost a few theoretical units on Fish, so we are perturbed. But who is surprised? At any of it? Fish is not a strong nine. He comes up small routinely. And it’s not as if he is so exhausted because he’s been winning titles left and right. To get grossly abused by Juan Monaco last week, and to have his soft forehand totally exploited, was unimpressive to say the least. We are happy to see this withdrawal.
Does Fish perhaps have Mono? Well, we wouldn’t like to see it. But we’d hate to see even more if Fish, claiming fatigue this week, ends up at Sabadell next week, ready to roll. Because that would belittle the Davis Cup and mock America. We think Fish should’ve gone to France. He has to get ready for red clay by playing on clay, and nothing is better than a good couple of best of five set matches. We think Fish is setting himself up for a poor clay season, which again, will not be surprising because it’s Mardy Fish we are talking about, and he’s bound to disappoint.
Ryan Harrison is a perfectly scrappy and quick player, and is well suited to the red clay. We’re comfortable saying this, even though we are having trouble finding any wins of his on European Clay. He won the Houston championship, upsetting James Blake, another all time dog. Small time pressure player. Courier had Harrison on the last squad and had him hitting with the team at points last year, and Courier is very comfortable with the selection. Harrison is going to be thrilled to get into to this tie, and he is going to do what he does, which is scrap and retrieve and limit the errors, hit the occasional winner, and flash a decent serve game and good hands at net. We think Harrison is setting up for a nice clay court season this year, and it will start this weekend. Getting some real big matches in over there is going to do worlds for him, and at #66, he is on the bubble for Masters Series events coming up, and may have to play in to a tourny through the qualifiers. This type of match play can be just what the doctor ordered for both Harrison and the US team.
Harrison is going to be a very good player, as perhaps Guy Forget is suggesting. But the kid is a good player now too, and he may be a matchup problem for Jo-Wilfried Tsonga, who he will play on Friday. Harrison is going to get a lot of balls back on this damp court. Tsonga is going to have a long day if he tries to muscle through the court. And you know Harrison is going to play his balls off. That’s his nature. It’s been only by a slim margin that he lost recent matches to very hot players like Federer, Murray, and Raonic.
We don’t think Tsonga or Simon are in that class. Harrison, yet to have a truly big notch on his belt, will also have a good opportunity in the reverse singles against Simon because they are mirror image players, and grinders sometimes have matchup problems with guys who grind really hard against them, and we feel Simon is that type of player. Harrison has young legs and a young spirit, and despite his lack of notches, you can tell he’s a true competitor and a smart player. He has also improved a great deal.
As for Fish, who will ever forget the absolute American nightmare at the 2004 Olympic Games in Athens, where he lost in the gold medal match to Nicolas Massu, losing after leading two sets to one? Then the problem was that Fish was fat. Now that Fish slimmed down and got with Stacey Gardner, he thinks he can play rally tennis and hits way more shots than he used to. He had to improve his footwork and did. But he still has to go for winners, and we don’t always see it. The more tennis he plays, the more air seems to creep under that forehand. Not a good thing. And if he is tired coming into clay season, how can he expect to survive it and prosper?
Obviously a lot is thought of the French squad. Vegas has them as the second favorite in the world group at (+400), second only behind champion Spain, at (+275). But Vegas was counting on Gael Monfils to be the French B player, and with him on slow dirt in France, that is a lot to handle. As it is, Harrison will go in and start things off against Tsonga in the first match on Friday morning. We like his chances, and we aren’t as scared of France in this spot as we could be. Everyone is going from hards to clay in this tie, and since America also did it in Switzerland against Federer and Wawrinka, we think they are in good shape.
It’s also nice to have the Bryans back together. The Bryan brothers have never lost in the Davis Cup on clay (9-0) and are truly the linchpin of the American squad.